Insolvency rarely arrives without warning. More often, it develops gradually: cash becomes tighter, creditors wait longer, tax and superannuation obligations accumulate, suppliers change their terms and management spends increasing amounts of time deciding which bills can be paid this week.
For directors, recognising the warning signs of insolvency early can be critical. It may create time to repair the business, refinance, restructure its debts or obtain the protection of a properly implemented safe harbour strategy. Waiting until the company is facing statutory demands, cancelled supply arrangements or exhausted banking facilities can leave far fewer options.
For Melbourne business owners asking, “Is my business insolvent?”, the starting point is not whether the company has valuable assets or expects a large sale next month. The central question is whether the company can pay its debts as and when they become due.
What Does “Insolvent” Mean Under Australian Law?
Section 95A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) provides that a person is solvent if, and only if, the person is able to pay all of their debts as and when they become due and payable. A company that cannot do so is insolvent.
This is commonly described as the cash flow insolvency test. But it is not simply a test of how much cash happens to be in the bank on a particular day. Courts look at the company’s financial position as a whole and at commercial realities. Relevant matters can include cash resources, debts falling due, assets that can realistically be sold or borrowed against within an appropriate time, available finance and the nature of the business.
That distinction matters. A temporary cash shortage does not necessarily mean a company is insolvent. Equally, a company may have assets worth more than its liabilities on paper and still be insolvent if those assets cannot be converted into funds in time to meet debts falling due.
There is therefore no single accounting ratio or isolated event that answers the question. Insolvency is ultimately a question of fact.
The 14 Indicators of Insolvency: The ASIC v Plymin Framework
One of the best-known Australian cases dealing with insolvency indicators is ASIC v Plymin, Elliott & Harrison [2003] VSC 123, often referred to as the Water Wheel case.
In that case, the Court referred to a list of 14 common features seen in insolvency situations. The list remains widely used by liquidators, lawyers and courts as a practical framework when considering whether a company may have been insolvent.
Importantly, the Plymin indicators are not a statutory test. A company does not become insolvent merely because one or more boxes are ticked, and there is no rule that a particular number of indicators establishes insolvency. They are warning signs that should prompt closer examination.
- Continuing losses.
- Liquidity ratios below 1.
- Overdue Commonwealth and State taxes.
- A poor relationship with the company’s bank, including an inability to borrow further funds.
- No access to alternative finance.
- Inability to raise further equity capital.
- Suppliers placing the company on cash-on-delivery terms, or demanding special payments before resuming supply.
- Creditors remaining unpaid outside normal trading terms.
- Issuing post-dated cheques.
- Dishonoured cheques.
- Special arrangements with selected creditors.
- Solicitors’ letters, summonses, judgments or warrants being issued against the company.
- Payments to creditors in rounded sums that cannot be reconciled to particular invoices.
- Inability to produce timely and accurate financial information showing the company’s trading performance and financial position, and allowing reliable forecasts to be prepared.
The first group of indicators concerns financial performance and the company’s ability to obtain funding. The next group concerns the way creditors are being managed and paid. The final indicator highlights something equally important: directors cannot properly assess solvency if they do not have reliable accounts, aged creditor information, tax balances and cash flow forecasts.
Some of the terminology in the original checklist also reflects payment practices at the time of the case. In a modern business, the equivalent of post-dated or dishonoured cheques may include failed direct debits, repeated requests for short extensions, irregular part-payments or paying whichever creditor is applying the greatest pressure rather than paying debts in an orderly way as they fall due.
If several of these warning signs of insolvency are appearing together, the correct response is not to count them and wait for a particular threshold. It is to investigate the company’s actual solvency position promptly.
If your business is showing a pattern of these warning signs, early advice can materially improve the options available. IRT Advisory provides confidential business insolvency assessments for Australian directors and business owners. Contact IRT Advisory.
Warning Signs of Insolvency That Are Easy to Miss
The formal Plymin indicators remain useful, but directors should also watch for modern insolvency indicators that may appear before a crisis becomes obvious.
One of the most common is using the ATO as an unofficial source of working capital. A business may continue paying wages and essential suppliers while allowing BAS, PAYG withholding or superannuation liabilities to accumulate. The business may appear to be trading normally, but in substance it is funding operations by not paying statutory liabilities when due.
This has become particularly important since the introduction of payday super and its implications for director liability from 1 July 2026. Superannuation contributions generally need to reach an employee’s super fund within seven business days after payday. The former quarterly payment cycle therefore no longer provides the same timing buffer.
Other warning signs include directors repeatedly injecting personal funds, increasing personal guarantees, maxing out credit cards, regularly extending the overdraft, delaying their own wages, losing key customers or contracts, or relying on the “next big job” to solve a continuing cash deficit.
Board disputes and director resignations can also matter. Sometimes those closest to the business recognise its deteriorating financial position before the accounts make the position obvious.
A particularly important warning sign is “robbing Peter to pay Paul”: paying only those creditors who are threatening supply stoppages or legal action while other debts continue to age. That may keep the doors open temporarily, but it does not establish that the company can pay all of its debts as they fall due.
Why Recognising the Signs Early Matters for Directors
Directors have a duty under section 588G of the Corporations Act to prevent a company from incurring debts in circumstances where the company is insolvent, or becomes insolvent by incurring those debts, and there are reasonable grounds for suspecting insolvency.
The consequences can be serious. Director liability for insolvent trading can include civil penalties and compensation claims for losses suffered by creditors. Where dishonesty is involved, criminal liability can also arise, including imprisonment.
The practical point is not that every company experiencing financial difficulty should immediately cease trading. It is that directors who suspect insolvency need to become properly informed and take appropriate action.
That may include considering safe harbour protection. Safe harbour is not a general licence to trade an insolvent company. Broadly, it can provide protection from civil insolvent trading liability for qualifying debts where, after insolvency is suspected, directors begin developing and taking a course of action reasonably likely to lead to a better outcome for the company than immediate administration or liquidation.
Accurate books and records also matter. A company is required to keep financial records that correctly record and explain its transactions and financial position. In an insolvent trading proceeding, inadequate financial records can also give rise to a statutory presumption of insolvency for the relevant period.
Early action therefore does two things: it gives the business a better chance of being rescued, and it helps directors demonstrate that they took their responsibilities seriously.
What to Do If You Recognise These Warning Signs
If the warning signs of insolvency are present, directors should move quickly from instinct and optimism to evidence.
Start with a realistic short-term cash flow forecast. A 13-week forecast is often useful because it forces the business to identify exactly when wages, rent, tax, superannuation, finance commitments and trade creditors will fall due, and what cash will actually be available to meet them.
Next, reconcile the company’s financial position. Review aged creditors and debtors, bank facilities, overdue ATO liabilities, superannuation, employee entitlements, finance agreements and any personal guarantees. Do not assume that slow-moving stock, disputed debtors or related-party receivables will be converted into cash at their book value.
Directors should also distinguish between a viable business with a debt problem and a business that is structurally loss-making. Restructuring old debt will not solve a business model that continues to generate new losses.
Depending on the circumstances, available options may include a negotiated business turnaround, refinancing or recapitalisation, small business restructuring, voluntary administration, safe harbour or, where the business cannot be saved, an orderly company liquidation.
For companies with significant ATO debt, directors should also understand the potential personal consequences of Director Penalty Notices and unpaid superannuation obligations.
Most importantly, do not wait for a creditor to make the decision for you. A statutory demand, cancelled banking facility, winding-up application or withdrawal of essential supply can rapidly remove restructuring options that may have been available only weeks earlier.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if my business is insolvent?
The legal question is whether the company can pay all of its debts as and when they become due and payable. Persistent inability to pay creditors, tax, superannuation or employees on time is a serious warning sign. The Plymin indicators can assist with an initial insolvency checklist for directors, but a proper solvency assessment should consider the company’s entire financial position and available resources.
Can my business be insolvent even if it has assets?
Yes. A company may own property, stock, equipment or other assets and still be cash-flow insolvent if those assets cannot realistically be converted into funds in time to meet debts when they fall due. A strong balance sheet does not automatically establish solvency.
Is my business insolvent just because it owes the ATO money?
Not necessarily. Overdue tax is one recognised indicator of insolvency, but it is not conclusive by itself. The concern increases where tax debt continually grows, lodgements fall behind, payment arrangements repeatedly fail, or the company is also struggling to pay other creditors.
What is the difference between a struggling business and an insolvent business?
A business can experience declining profits, temporary cash pressure or a difficult trading period and remain solvent. Insolvency arises when the company is unable to pay its debts as and when they become due and payable. The distinction between temporary illiquidity and insolvency can be highly fact-specific.
What should a director do if the company may be insolvent?
Obtain reliable financial information, prepare a short-term cash flow forecast and seek advice promptly from an appropriately qualified insolvency professional. Depending on the circumstances, options may include business turnaround, safe harbour, small business restructuring, voluntary administration or liquidation.
Act Before the Options Narrow
The warning signs of insolvency are rarely improved by ignoring them. In many cases, the greatest value comes from recognising the problem while the company still has cash, customers, employees, banking support and time to make decisions.
If your business is unable to pay debts when due, is falling behind with the ATO or superannuation, or is increasingly dependent on creditor forbearance, it is worth having the position independently assessed.
IRT Advisory assists Australian directors and business owners to understand whether their company is solvent, what obligations they have and which restructuring or insolvency options remain available.
Learn more about our business insolvency services or contact IRT Advisory for a confidential discussion.
Based in Melbourne, IRT Advisory assists companies and directors throughout Victoria to assess their financial position, understand their obligations and explore the options available to them.